AH-64E Apache vs Ka-52 Alligator
The world's two most capable attack helicopters face off
AH-64E Apache
United States 路 In service 2011
The AH-64E Apache Guardian is the most advanced variant of the world's most battle-proven attack helicopter. It features upgraded engines, a new transmission, advanced networking for manned-unmanned teaming, and the ability to control UAVs from the cockpit.
Ka-52 Alligator
Russia 路 In service 2011
The Ka-52 is Russia's primary attack helicopter, featuring a distinctive coaxial rotor system that eliminates the tail rotor and provides exceptional agility. Its side-by-side cockpit allows both crew members to fly and fight, providing redundancy in combat.
The Matchup
The Apache and Ka-52 are the premier attack helicopters of the US and Russia respectively. The Apache brings Longbow radar and decades of combat data; the Ka-52 counters with its unique coaxial rotor and ejection seats.
Performance Radar
Rating Breakdown
Specifications
| Specification | AH-64E Apache | Ka-52 Alligator |
|---|---|---|
| Max Speed | 182 mph (293 km/h) | 186 mph (300 km/h) |
| Range | 295 mi (476 km) | 683 mi (1,100 km) with ferry tanks |
| Service Ceiling | 21,000 ft | 18,000 ft |
| Weapons | M230 30mm chain gun + AGM-114 Hellfire + Hydra 70 rockets + AIM-92 Stinger | 2A42 30mm autocannon + Vikhr-1 ATGMs + S-8/S-13 rockets + Igla AAMs |
| Max Weapons Load | 3,200 lb (1,451 kg) | 4,400 lb (2,000 kg) |
| Crew | 2 | 2 |
| Engine | 2x GE T700-GE-701D (1,994 shp each) | 2x Klimov VK-2500 (2,400 shp each) |
| Unit Cost | $35.5M (FY2023) | $16M (estimated) |
Strengths & Weaknesses
AH-64E Apache
Strengths
- + Most combat-proven attack helicopter in history
- + Longbow millimeter-wave radar for fire-and-forget targeting
- + Manned-unmanned teaming capability with drone control
- + Massive international operator base with proven logistics
Weaknesses
- - High acquisition and operating costs
- - Complex systems require extensive maintenance
- - Heavier than most competitors, limits high-altitude performance
- - Large radar and infrared signature
Ka-52 Alligator
Strengths
- + Coaxial rotor system eliminates tail rotor vulnerability
- + Side-by-side cockpit provides crew redundancy
- + Ejection seats, unique among attack helicopters
- + Good high-altitude and hot-weather performance
Weaknesses
- - Coaxial rotor is mechanically complex
- - Vikhr ATGMs require laser guidance during flight
- - Combat losses in Ukraine exposed survivability gaps
- - Electronics and sensors lag behind Western equivalents
Verdict
The Apache holds clear advantages in sensors, networking, and combat-proven systems. The Ka-52 is more agile and offers unique survivability features, but combat in Ukraine has exposed significant vulnerabilities to modern air defenses.